Skip to content
Cost & Savings

EV vs Petrol: True Cost of Ownership Comparison 2026

Is an electric car really cheaper to own than a petrol car? The answer used to be a simple yes: no road tax, cheap home charging and almost no servici

08 November 2026 5 min read EVRoadTax editorial

Is an electric car really cheaper to own than a petrol car? The answer used to be a simple yes: no road tax, cheap home charging and almost no servicing. In 2026 the picture is more complicated. Electric cars now pay road tax, electricity is no longer cheap, and the cars themselves cost more to buy. This guide compares the two side by side — road tax, fuel, servicing, insurance and depreciation — and works out the real three-year cost of a Tesla Model Y against a comparable petrol SUV, using verified figures only.

All figures in this guide were checked on 9 November 2026.

Road tax: the gap is gone

The biggest change in the last two years is road tax. Electric cars in the UK now pay vehicle excise duty, and from the second year onwards the standard rate is the same as for a petrol car: £200 a year. The tax gap that used to be worth £200 a year to an EV owner has closed.

Tesla Model Y (electric)VW Tiguan 1.5 eTSI (petrol)
List price£44,990£38,050
First-year road tax£10£560
Standard annual rate, years 2 and 3£200 a year£200 a year
Expensive-car supplementNo — under the £50,000 EV thresholdNo — under the £40,000 petrol threshold
Road tax over 3 years£410£960

The electric car still wins on road tax, but only in the first year. A new electric car pays £10 in its first year because it emits no CO2, while the Tiguan's first-year rate is £560 because its 135 g/km of CO2 puts it in the 131–150 g/km band. From year two both cars pay the same £200 a year. Neither car pays the £440-a-year expensive-car supplement: the threshold is £50,000 for electric cars and £40,000 for petrol cars, and both cars sit below their threshold.

That is a narrower advantage than it used to be, and it will narrow further. From April 2028 the government has announced a per-mile charge for electric vehicles — 3p a mile for battery electric cars — on top of the annual rate. The Finance Bill to introduce it was read a first time on 3 November 2026, but it is not yet law. See our UK EV road tax guide for the full rates, and our US state EV fees guide for how the same question is handled across the Atlantic, where 41 states charge electric cars an annual fee.

Fuel vs charging: cost per mile

This is where the electric car still wins by a large margin. The maths is simple once you have the two prices and the two efficiency figures.

Unleaded petrol averaged 172.78p a litre in the week commencing 2 November 2026, according to the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero weekly road fuel prices. The Tiguan returns 46.3 miles per gallon on the WLTP combined cycle, which is 10.19 miles per litre — so a litre of petrol carries the Tiguan 10.19 miles at 172.78p, or about 17.0p a mile.

Electricity on the Ofgem price cap, in force from 1 October to 31 December 2026, costs 26.32p per kWh for a typical direct-debit customer. The Model Y uses about 3.9 miles per kWh in the real world, according to EV Database's real-world estimate for this exact car — so a kilowatt-hour carries it 3.9 miles at 26.32p, or about 6.7p a mile. On an off-peak electric vehicle tariff, the figure falls further: Intelligent Octopus Go charges 7.9p per kWh overnight, which works out at about 2.0p a mile.

PriceEfficiencyCost per mile
Petrol (Tiguan, 46.3 mpg WLTP)172.78p per litre10.19 miles per litre17.0p
Electricity, price cap (Model Y)26.32p per kWh3.9 miles per kWh6.7p
Electricity, off-peak EV tariff (Model Y)7.9p per kWh3.9 miles per kWh2.0p

At the average UK annual mileage of 7,100 miles, the Tiguan burns about 697 litres of petrol a year, costing about £1,205. The Model Y uses about 1,821 kWh a year: about £479 on the price-cap rate, or about £144 on the off-peak tariff. The fuel saving is about £726 a year at the cap rate, or about £1,061 a year off-peak.

Two caveats. First, the Tiguan's 46.3 mpg is a WLTP laboratory figure; real-world economy will be lower, which would make the petrol cost per mile higher — but we could not verify a real-world figure for this trim, so the table uses the WLTP number and labels it as such. Second, these figures assume home charging. If you can only charge publicly, the saving shrinks — check the per-kWh price of the networks you would use before relying on these numbers.

Servicing: the EV is cheaper, but not by much

Electric cars have fewer moving parts — no oil, no clutch, no exhaust, no gearbox in the conventional sense — and the servicing figures reflect that, though the gap is smaller than the folklore suggests. Cap HPI's three-year servicing, maintenance and repair data puts an electric car at £1,486 over three years against £1,610 for a petrol car: a saving of £124. Per service, BookMyGarage's 2026 bookings data, reported by The Motor Ombudsman, averages £103 for an electric car against £151 for a petrol car.

Insurance: the EV costs a little more

Insurance is the one running cost where the electric car loses. MoneySuperMarket's November 2026 statistics put the average annual premium at £547 for an electric car against £503 for a petrol car — a gap of £44 a year, or about 9%. Other 2026 sources quote wider gaps, but the MoneySuperMarket pair is the one we verified first-hand, so it is the figure used here.

The gap exists for a few reasons: electric cars cost more to buy, so there is more to insure; repairs need specialist parts and technicians; and the cars are heavier, which can mean more damage in a collision. The gap has been narrowing as repair networks grow and more electric cars reach the used market.

Depreciation: the honest answer is that nobody knows yet

Depreciation is the largest single cost of owning any new car, and it is also the hardest to predict for electric cars. Published figures conflict. EVCompared, citing Cap HPI and Cox Automotive, reports the Model Y retaining about 69% of its value after three years, with the average electric car losing 38–42% over three years against 35–40% for an equivalent petrol car. US-based analyses, driven by Tesla's price cuts in 2023–24, put the Model Y at only 47–53% retained after three years — but those are not UK figures. For the Tiguan, older data suggests about 50% retained after three years and 36,000 miles, with no published figure for the current generation.

Because no like-for-like, UK-specific, three-year depreciation pair exists from a single authoritative source, depreciation is left out of the worked example below. Treat it as a sensitivity: if the Model Y holds 60% and the Tiguan 50%, the electric car gains about £4,500 over three years; if both hold 50%, it gains nothing.

Three-year worked example: Model Y vs Tiguan

Two mid-size five-seat family SUVs, both bought new in 2026, both driven 7,100 miles a year — the UK average — for three years, or 21,300 miles in total. Every figure below is verified and sourced; every assumption is labelled.

AssumptionValue
Annual mileage7,100 miles (UK average, DfT National Travel Survey)
Period3 years, 21,300 miles
Petrol price172.78p per litre (DESNZ, week commencing 2 November 2026)
Electricity price26.32p per kWh (Ofgem cap) or 7.9p per kWh (off-peak EV tariff)
Model Y efficiency3.9 miles per kWh (EV Database real-world estimate)
Tiguan economy46.3 mpg (WLTP combined — laboratory figure)
DepreciationExcluded — no verifiable like-for-like figure (see above)
Cost over 3 yearsTesla Model YVW Tiguan 1.5 eTSI
Purchase price£44,990£38,050
Fuel / charging£1,438 (cap) / £431 (off-peak)£3,613
Road tax£410£960
Servicing (Cap HPI)£1,486£1,610
Insurance (MoneySuperMarket)£1,641£1,509
Running costs, 3 years£4,975 (cap) / £3,968 (off-peak)£7,692
Purchase + running, 3 years£49,965 (cap) / £48,958 (off-peak)£45,742

The electric car saves £2,717 on running costs over three years at the price-cap electricity rate, or £3,724 on the off-peak tariff — about £906 to £1,241 a year. But it costs £6,940 more to buy. Over three years the petrol car is still £4,223 cheaper in total at the cap rate, or £3,216 cheaper off-peak. The electric car does not pay for itself in three years on these figures.

The break-even point, on fuel savings alone and assuming today's prices hold, is roughly 6 to 8 years: about 7.7 years at the price-cap rate and about 5.6 years on the off-peak tariff. That is derived arithmetic from the figures above, not a published forecast. The conclusion is sensitive to three things: how much you drive, whether you can charge at home off-peak, and depreciation — excluded here, and capable of swinging the result either way.

Where the EV still wins big

For a private buyer paying cash, the honest answer in 2026 is that the electric car wins on running costs and loses on purchase price, with the balance tipping in its favour only after several years. For a company-car driver the answer is different: benefit-in-kind tax on a pure electric car is 4% of its list price in 2026/27, against up to 37% for a petrol car. On a £45,000 car that is a taxable benefit of £1,800 a year for the electric car, against up to £16,650 for the petrol equivalent.

Home charging is the other big lever. The difference between the price-cap rate and the off-peak tariff is worth about £335 a year at average mileage — more than the entire road-tax bill. A driveway and an off-peak tariff are worth more to an electric car owner than any tax break currently on offer.

For the tax picture in each country, see our guides to UK EV road tax, Malaysia EV road tax and US state EV fees, the full list of countries we cover — including Malaysia, the Netherlands, Germany and Ireland — and our methodology and sources page. If you are choosing between specific models, the Tesla Model Y, Tesla Model 3 and Cupra Born pages show the road tax for each car year by year.

Frequently asked questions

Is an electric car really cheaper to run than a petrol car?

Yes, on running costs: about £906 to £1,241 a year cheaper in our worked example, mostly from fuel. But the electric car costs more to buy — £6,940 more in our example — so over three years the petrol car is still cheaper in total. The electric car pulls ahead after roughly 6 to 8 years on fuel savings alone.

How much does it cost per mile to fuel an EV vs a petrol car?

About 6.7p a mile for the Model Y on the price-cap electricity rate, or 2.0p a mile on an off-peak EV tariff, against about 17.0p a mile for the Tiguan on petrol at 172.78p a litre. Those are the figures for November 2026.

Do EVs pay the same road tax as petrol cars now?

From the second year onwards, yes: £200 a year for both. The first year differs — a new electric car pays £10, while a petrol car's first-year rate depends on its CO2, £560 for the Tiguan at 135 g/km. The expensive-car supplement threshold is £50,000 for electric cars and £40,000 for petrol cars.

Are EVs more expensive to insure?

On average, yes, by a small amount: £547 a year for an electric car against £503 for a petrol car, according to MoneySuperMarket's November 2026 statistics — a gap of £44 a year.

Do EVs cost less to service?

Yes, but the gap is modest: Cap HPI puts three-year servicing, maintenance and repair at £1,486 for an electric car against £1,610 for a petrol car, a saving of £124. Per service, the average is £103 against £151.

What about depreciation?

It is the biggest cost and the hardest to predict. Published figures conflict — one source has the Model Y retaining about 69% after three years, US-based analyses put it at 47–53% — and there is no published figure for the current Tiguan. We left depreciation out of the worked example rather than publish a number we could not stand behind.

How long until the EV pays for itself?

On fuel savings alone, roughly 6 to 8 years at today's prices: about 7.7 years on the price-cap electricity rate, about 5.6 years on an off-peak tariff. More miles, cheaper overnight charging or a company-car tax arrangement all bring that forward; depreciation could move it either way.

Does home charging make the biggest difference?

Yes. Charging at home on an off-peak tariff costs 7.9p per kWh against 26.32p on the standard price-cap rate — a difference worth about £335 a year at average mileage. These figures assume home charging; if you can only charge publicly, the saving shrinks, so check the per-kWh price of the networks you would use.

Sources

  • GOV.UK — Vehicle tax rate tables: https://www.gov.uk/vehicle-tax-rate-tables
  • GOV.UK — Company car benefit: the appropriate percentage (480 Appendix 2): https://www.gov.uk/guidance/company-car-benefit-the-appropriate-percentage-480-appendix-2
  • DESNZ — Weekly road fuel prices (week commencing 2 November 2026), via PetrolPrices: https://www.petrolprices.co.uk/fuel-price-index.php
  • Ofgem — Energy price cap unit rates and standing charges (1 October – 31 December 2026): https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/your-energy-supply/your-energy-bill/energy-price-cap-unit-rates-and-standing-charges
  • Octopus EV — Energy tariffs for electric cars (Intelligent Octopus Go, updated 4 November 2026): https://octopusev.com/ev-hub/energy-tariffs-electric-cars
  • EV Database — Tesla Model Y Standard RWD: https://ev-database.org/uk/car/3362/Tesla-Model-Y-Standard-RWD
  • Carwow — Tesla Model Y prices: https://www.carwow.co.uk/tesla/model-y
  • EVCompared — Tesla Model Y and Model 3 UK prices in October 2026: https://www.evcompared.co.uk/news/tesla-model-y-model-3-uk-prices-october-2026/
  • Carwow — Volkswagen Tiguan prices: https://www.carwow.co.uk/volkswagen/tiguan
  • Parkers — Volkswagen Tiguan SUV (2024 on) car tax: https://www.PARKERS.CO.UK/volkswagen/tiguan/suv-2024/car-tax/
  • Listers — Volkswagen Tiguan 1.5 eTSI Life (CO2 135 g/km): https://listers.co.uk/new/cars/volkswagen/tiguan/1.5_etsi_life/104444
  • Cap HPI 3-year servicing data, via Autodoc: https://www.autodoc.co.uk/info/how-much-does-it-really-cost-to-run-an-electric-car-in-the-uk
  • The Motor Ombudsman — How much does an electric car service cost (BookMyGarage 2026 data): https://www.themotorombudsman.org/motoring-advice/how-much-does-an-electric-car-service-cost/
  • MoneySuperMarket — Car insurance statistics (November 2026): https://www.moneysupermarket.com/car-insurance/car-insurance-statistics/
  • RAC Foundation — Motoring FAQs, average annual mileage (DfT National Travel Survey): https://www.racfoundation.org/motoring-faqs/mobility
  • EVCompared — Used electric cars hold their value (Cap HPI / Cox Automotive): https://www.evcompared.co.uk/news/used-electric-cars-hold-their-value/

Last checked: 9 November 2026.